When so many good people are trying so hard to prevent suicide among our military members, why do the numbers continue to climb?
One factor that we may be ignoring is the effect that all this media attention may have on the suicide rate. Especially in tight-knit communities like the military. Especially among members of the population who are under 24 years old.
Since 1974, it has been established that suicide imitation can be spread inadvertently by media. Sociologist David Phillips called it “The Werther Effect.” Other scientists refer to it as “media contagion.” Whatever you call it, certain details of news coverage of a suicide -- such as describing exactly how a person died and publishing tributes from family members --have been shown to significantly increase the rate of suicide deaths.
The Center for Disease Control, the Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration, and the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services all published guidelines to prevent that media contagion from happening.
Those guidelines are not being followed with military members. In a 2011 study, Amanda Edwards-Stewart and her colleagues reviewed 240 military and civilian newspaper reports of suicide from 15 different sources for compliance with the guidelines. Nearly all reviewed articles violated at least one guideline. The researchers found that military suicides were more likely to be reported in the news than those in the civilian population. Ineffective behavioral health treatment was more likely to be noted as a contributing factor to the suicide.
“Such emphasis can imply that seeking help for depression and suicide may lead to suicide instead of preventing it. This may be especially damaging to the military population, for whom stigma regarding behavioral health care prevents treatment-seeking.”
We can see examples of this kind of media contagion everywhere right now. The coverage is undeniably well meant. For example, the recent TIME magazine article about military suicide violated many of the CDC guidelines. The article had prominent placement on the cover of the magazine. There was some “glorification” of the two members of the military who were featured. There were complete descriptions exactly how both servicemembers killed themselves and the grief experienced when each of them was found. The reporters described just how the servicemembers sought help for behavioral health and exactly how the help failed.
That is exactly the kind of coverage that has been shown to increase suicide imitation.
Yet the article was well-researched. Insightful. Respectful of the military families involved. It exposed the idea that suicide is not confined to the heavily deployed -- a third of the suicides occurred among those who had never deployed and 43 percent occurred among those who had deployed only once. It revealed that the servicemembers knew exactly what to say to avoid further scrutiny. It revealed how one servicemember sought help from behavioral professionals six times. Six times.
We cannot afford to ignore the suicide rate in our community. We cannot pretend these deaths are not happening. We also have to be aware that certain kinds of attention exacerbate the problem. Which puts us smack in a classic military Catch 22, walking a line between the living and the dead, hoping we can do the right thing.
Jacey Eckhart is the former Director of Spouse and Family Programs at Military.com and a military sociologist. Since 1996, Eckhart’s take on military families has been featured in her syndicated column, her book The Homefront Club, and her award winning CDs These Boots and I Married a Spartan??
Most recently she has been featured as a military family subject matter expert on NBC Dateline, CBS morning news, CNN, NPR and the New York Times. Eckhart is an Air Force brat, a Navy wife and an Army mom.
“Where are you from?” “Um [slight pause]…well my husband and I are originally from Indiana, but we lived in Tennessee until just recently. Now we live in Georgia.” Does this sound familiar? Maybe with different states but still the same rambling that just adds confusion and no clear answer. I have been a military spouse ... Continue Reading