DefenseWatch These articles and commentaries are provided courtesy of DefenseWatch, the official magazine for Soldiers For The Truth (SFTT), a grass-roots educational organization started by a small group of concerned veterans and citizens to inform the public, the Congress, and the media on the decline in readiness of our armed forces. Inspired by the outspoken idealism of retired Colonel David Hackworth, SFTT aims to give our service people, veterans, and retirees a clear voice with the media, Congress, the public and their services. Related Links: Article Archive Military Base Guide Hot Discussions Have an opinion on this commentary? Sound off. DefenseWatch Website Get Breaking Military News Alerts Related Links Marine Corps Community Center Article: Study Long-Term Impact of New USMC Policy Get Breaking Military News Alerts

  Email this page to friends

"Having spent two tours and a total of three years in Oki, I think I have a little bit to say about the policy... On many levels, Okinawa is far different than other overseas military bases around the world... Okinawa, while a well-populated island, is not wrought with recreational opportunities. Much of the population is not overly friendly with the U.S. forces, and other than the marine park or scuba diving, not much else is of particular interest to the average Marine. Costs for doing simple things such as eating at a restaurant are so high as to essentially eliminate this as a viable option for the junior enlisted Marine... Organized intramurals or picnics can only go so far in keeping morale up and having excess youthful energy expended."

"Even 1 year away from your family brings a lot of hardships and I am just glad that I will not have to do a 2-year tour while I am married. I believe that extending the tours from 1 to 2 years would cause problems for Marines that were married. I do not think that single Marines will be affected as much as married ones are... I believe that the two-year tours to Oki will be destructive to families if Marines opt to leave their families in the States and go accompanied for two years. We already have enough marital problems."

"My only question is if at the 12-month mark, will Marines be offered the same incentives (plane ticket to home of record, or extra leave, or $2,000) currently on the table for those considering extending for another year?"

"Been years since this old Marine has been on the Rock. What's changed to make it such a gala place? Can we find liberty runs to Hong Kong, PI, or other places for just plain liberty, like we used to do for RVN R&R? Two years there would be enough to scare me. When we owned the Island and dictated what we were going to do, we could have made it a better place."

"Single Marines living in Oki are essentially in a situation of enforced celibacy, and while this is bad enough for one year, most 19-year-old Marines would find a 2-year stint of not dating to be unbearable. And for every Marine who gets a chance to go to Korea, Thailand, or the Philippines on an operation, three Marines will be stuck on the island for the entire 2 years."

"Army troops in Europe can easily hop a train and go to Paris, Rome, Amsterdam, etc on a three-day weekend. Marines on Oki do not have that type of opportunity. They are on Oki, and they will stay on Oki."

"From mid-1997 through about mid-1999, unaccompanied "fresh-out-of-school" 2nd lt's in the Air-Ground [military occupational specialties] MOS's who were sent to 1st [Marine Air Wing] were given 24-month unaccompanied orders. This was an arrangement made by the monitors and the senior officers of those MOS's already 'on-island'. This was done in order to curtail the high turnover... Shiny, new 2nd lt's would spend a year there, rotate and take with them a year's worth of experience, only to be replaced by another 2nd lt who would repeat the process. His peers [stateside] would spend the requisite 36 months there, go to [career level school], then a [supporting establishment] billet, then back to the [operating forces] leaving the Okinawa units with mid-level captains and new 2nd lt's, except for the occasional lt who would extend for another year ... I was one of those 2nd lt's given 24-month orders, and can attest to the benefits of 2-year tours for all Marines in Okinawa. The cohesion, camaraderie, and 'operational readiness' that we had cannot be developed as well over the course of just one year."

"As far as military training, Okinawa is basically garrison duty. Other than small-unit tactics, training opportunities are quite sub-par. The longer Marines are kept on Oki, the more their skills atrophy when compared to Marines stationed elsewhere... Now the Japanese call the shots and it's hard to even train like we're going to war. Maybe we should consider moving our forward presence to a more accommodating place?"

"I have been stationed on Okinawa a total of 4 different times from 1988 to my most recent 2003 Unit Deployment. I think you're missing the point. There is no need to have anybody forward deployed to Okinawa or a 3rd Marine Division [Mar Div] for that matter. After the end of the Cold War the 3rd Mar Div became the public relations division of the far east. They do not partake in any relevant real-world missions nor is any of the training preparing you for it. While [Camp Pendleton, CA-based] I [Marine Expeditionary Force] MEF and part of [Camp LeJeune, NC-based] II MEF fight the fight, active-duty Marines in the 3rd Mar Div go crazy as every National Guard and reserve unit goes off to defend the country. It sucks being a prize fighter and never getting a shot at the Title."

"Three year accompanied tours are fine. But I firmly believe that two-year unaccompanied tours will decrease retention and cause more problems vis-a-vis interaction with the local population. I believe we will see more incidents which will cause strife between the Marines and the Okinawans... As for the Marine Corps saying that this would make the Marines that get stationed there act more like it was their home and want to learn more about the culture in Japan, I doubt it will do that."