DoD Test of Viral Spread on Commercial Planes Reveals Good News, General Says

Airflow particle test on board a United Airlines 767 aircraft.
David Silcott, left, chief executive of S3i, goes over an airflow particle test for Navy Vice Adm. Dee Mewbourne, right, deputy commander, U.S. Transportation Command, on board a United Airlines 767 aircraft at Dulles International Airport, Va., Aug. 28, 2020. (DoD/ Stephenie Wade)

The head of U.S. Transportation Command offered a sneak preview Wednesday of the results of a Defense Department test of particulate spread on commercial aircraft -- and they are surprising.

Speaking at the National Defense Transportation Association's annual fall meeting, Gen. Stephen Lyons cited an aerosol test held Aug. 24-31 aboard two large passenger aircraft: the Boeing 767-300 and 777-200. The Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency, better known as DARPA, teamed up with biodefense company Zeteo Tech Inc. to evaluate in-flight spread of airborne particles. Industry partners included Boeing and United Airlines.

Read Next: Trump's Former Lawyer Vows to Help in Air Force Vet Reality Winner's Appeal

"[The test] was an initiative initiated by TRANSCOM and supported by the Air Force and the test community to determine whether it's safe to fly on commercial airliners," Lyons said Wednesday. "And I have to tell you, their results, as were the results when we looked at this from the COVID patient movement challenge, are very, very encouraging."

There are some qualifiers, Lyons noted. The conditions that yielded positive results, he said, involved aircraft with HEPA filtration and "a very, very high air exchange rate of every two to five minutes or two to three minutes."

But under those conditions, he indicated, particle spread rates were even lower than in a conventional indoor setting.

"In fact, I would tell you that in my observations, and I've flown commercially since the pandemic started, being on a commercial airplane with HEPA filtration is probably one of the safest places that you can be," Lyons said. "And those test reports will be out very, very soon."

According to a September Defense Department test, TRANSCOM undertook this research in order to determine the safety of DoD-contracted Patriot Express, or commercial charter flights, used to transport military family members and others on official duty. The tests were conducted on a 767 and 777, officials said, because those are the aircraft most typically used for these flights.

According to the release, fluorescent tracer particles meant to simulate viral particles were released at rates of 2 to 4 minutes, both in the air and on the ground. Mannequins representing passengers were positioned throughout the aircraft, some wearing masks and some without.

The evaluators also tested a variety of scenarios, releasing particles in the cockpit as well as in the cabin, at the terminal with the cabin door open and at the terminal with doors closed but with air recirculation via an auxiliary power unit.

"The test will help U.S. TRANSCOM understand the aerosol particle field generated by a passenger shedding viral material and the exposure risk to crew and passengers," Navy Lt. Cmdr. Joseph Pope, TRANSCOM operations directorate liaison for the airflow particle test, said in a statement.

Lyons did not offer details in his address about any differences in test outcome for masked and nonmasked passengers, whether position in the aircraft made a difference or what specific scenario outcomes showed.

According to the release, test results were due to TRANSCOM in September and then set to be reported to the Defense Department's COVID-19 task force.

The Defense Department, which shut down most "Space-A" passenger travel at the start of the pandemic in March, cautiously restarted flights in May with extensive restrictions, including mask-wearing and 14-day quarantine upon arrival. Once released, the full results of the test could change procedures for passenger transport.

"This data collected will eventually inform the Department of Defense on contact tracing requirements needed for specific aircraft," Pope said in the September release. "It will also be used to develop strategies like cabin loading and seating configurations to mitigate potential risk of inter-person transmission of the aerosol particles."

In addition, he said, the tests could help determine who needs to self-quarantine if it's discovered a passenger on their aircraft tested positive for COVID-19.

"It could be the difference between the whole aircraft isolating compared to one person," Pope said.

-- Hope Hodge Seck can be reached at Follow her on Twitter at @HopeSeck.

Related: Trump Orders DoD, VA and Other Agencies to Probe Link Between Pandemic and Suicides

Story Continues