Home
Benefits
News
entertainment
shop
finance
careers
education
join military
community
 
Search for Military News:  
The Passdown Early Brief | Headlines | Warfighter's Forum | Discussions | Benefit Updates | Defense Tech
I Don't Want to be a Milblogger
Bruce Kesler | June 26, 2006
I've been out of the Marine Corps for three-and-a-half decades. Most of what I know, or remember, about combat tactics is out-of-date. I don't nor do I want to own a gun, my only one being the M-16 back then. I'm probably too old to fight, or even run.

Most of what I write about at Democracy-Project.com is not about the war in Iraq or Afghanistan. I prefer to write about today's problems with healthcare, something I have more current firsthand knowledge about. Good milbloggers are in the combat zones, or have current experience, so understand and focus upon the details that aren't presented in the major media.

Still, many of my posts are about the current war, and more particularly about the media coverage. As an ordinary citizen, I'm concerned to get reliable reporting upon which to make judgments. And, I live in San Diego, where I have to face the many sincere, squared away Marines and sailors whom I see on the street.

We aren't getting that reliable reporting. Indeed, we usually aren't getting much of any reporting about what's happening at the front, the who, what, when, where, why. Instead, most newspaper columns and TV reports focus on a list of casualties, the inside politics in the Green Zone, or speculations built on little information about the latest prejudged atrocity by U.S. forces. Much of that information is provided, and passed along by our mainstream media without critical comment or qualifications, from often suspect Iraqi stringers and press manipulators among our foes.

For the most glaring and recent example, just look at the media brouhaha over Haditha, where some Marines reacting to an attack upon them are under investigation for possibly exceeding the rules of engagement in the deaths of Iraqis. For several weeks, the major media has gone through a succession of sensationalist stories about the incident, and as one of their story lines gets exposed the media blithely goes on to the next one.

  • First the suspect “evidence” that Time magazine's Tim McGirk, who broke the story, reports a major human rights organization delivered: a video of what is presented as the results of a Marine rampage, which demonstrates nothing of the kind. Then, that major human rights organization turns out to be a twosome of hostile Iraqis, who in the latest of a series of corrections from McGirk, even “they didn't know much about it, they just knew that it came from Haditha.”

  • It's now revealed that McGirk's editor at Time magazine displayed who he instead distrusted, refusing to send McGirk under military protection to Haditha to get more facts, as he didn't want to “put our safety in the hands of the men that we were then going to turn around and accuse of having gone on a rampage and killed civilians.”

  • Then, the Iraqi “witnesses” whose allegations the Marines went on a killing rampage are headlined are revealed telling conflicting, contradictory and changing narratives;

  • So, then, when several of the Marines' attorneys speak to correct the record, the New York Times weighs in with two anonymous sources whose qualifications are not otherwise detailed to say that some of the secret investigation in progress contradicts the Marines.
In fact, there is nothing yet known about the forensics or other thorough investigations conducted by the military. And, the Iraqis' families refuse autopsies to get better facts. What is known is that much of the media tabloid-level speculation has been discredited, but not before the reputation of the Marines and our country has been disparaged on their front pages around the world.

By contrast, narratives of our heroes is mighty scarce in our leading media. I haven't counted. But, the conservative Media Research Center has. The MRC says that, “Since the war on terror began, the military has awarded top medals to 20 individuals…None have been given more than a fraction of the attention that the latest allegations against the military have received.” MRC notes, “In fact, 14 of the country's top 20 medal recipients have gone unmentioned by ABC, CBS and NBC.”

I don't want to be a milblogger. However, they, and I to a lesser extent, are forced to be by the severe and serious failure of our mainstream media to provide even elemental balance, not to mention factual reliability.

None of us want another My Lai. And, some commentators are so sensitive to avoiding one that they are willing to jump to conclusions about current allegations, while others just look for such an opportunity in order to malign the current policies. They are not, however, serving truth but, rather, an agenda, not taking the time to define the differences or the contrary evidence.

Whether you support the war or administration or policies, you owe it to yourself to at least be better informed before making judgments. MudvilleGazette.com, for example, offers a morning roundup of all the best milblogs and mainstream reporting about Iraq and Afghanistan. It's easy and fast. And, it's a lot more than you're getting from the tube or your local newspaper.

This column first appeared in the Washington Examiner

Sound Off...What do you think? Join the discussion.


Copyright 2012 Bruce Kesler. All opinions expressed in this article are the author's and do not necessarily reflect those of Military.com.

 
About Bruce Kesler

Bruce Kesler, Vietnam veteran, lives in Encinitas, CA, where he owns an employee benefits consulting and brokerage firm. He is a contributing writer for the Democracy Project