Home
Benefits
News
entertainment
shop
finance
careers
education
join military
community
 
Search for Military News:  
Forum Forum Home | Headlines | Early Brief | Opinions | Discussions | SoldierTech | Benefit Updates | Defense Tech
Shiloh From Both Sides
Lines of Fire | November 28, 2005
“The musketry was at times as regular as hail falling on the roof of the house interrupted by cannon balls belching its insides out which cut off many limbs…”

“O Mary you could never form an idea of the horrors of actual war unless you saw the battlefields while the conflict is progressing...”

Background information and commentary by Andrew Carroll : Although the vast majority of wartime correspondences sent to the Legacy Project are from the two world wars and all major conflicts since, we do receive many letters from the Civil War. The most interesting to me are the ones by troops on opposing sides of the same battle, and the following letters were written by two men who had survived Shiloh. (With 25,000 casualties, there were more combat dead and wounded from this single battle than from three entire U.S. wars—the Revolution, the War of 1812, and the Mexican-American War—combined.) The first letter is by a young Scottish-born Union soldier named David R. Stevenson, who wrote to his father on April 13, 1862. (The full text of this letter appears in BEHIND THE LINES.)

Dear Sir:

I take my pen in hand to write you a few lines informing you that I am in the land of the living and well and unhurt. I see by the Cincinnati Times that there was a tremendous battle fought here on Sunday and Monday the 6th and 7th. If you had been here you would thought so too. The rebles commenced the attack about day break. They drove us all to the river landing or closed us up till our Army covered about one mile square when three gun boats opened fire up a ravine and they fell like grass before a scythe…

At daybreak our army opened fire on the enemy, Beulls force it was that opened the Ball the second day, his force having arrived during the night. Boath armies fought terrible during the second day till about noon when the rebles began to retreat which they kept up till four oclock when they started for Corinth every fellow for himself and the devil for all. They went like our men went from Manassas in great confusion.

Out loss is between seven and ten thousand killed and 30 or 40 thousand wounded. The loss of the enemy is larger than ours. Some of the dead rebles was not buried untill yesterday the Job being a big one it took several days & the horses is unburied yet and smell very loud…

Daton randall kill the first morning, forg michell wounded in the forhead by buckshot reported from the hospital dead. The musketry was at times as regular as hail falling on the roof of the house interrupted by cannon balls belching its insides out which cut off many limbs which fell on and hurt many off our men  some of the balls going through trees two feet in diameter. The trees are all bulletmarked some having the balls in them.

I was not directly in the battle the first day. I was unloading the wounded all the first day till night when I went with a boat load to Savannah ten miles below. I waited on 20 men day & night untill Tuesday morning when I left and came up here on a boat… I wrote when in camp Dennison. If you expect any more letters from me you will have to answer this to insure it.

D. R. Stevenson

----------
At about the same time Stevenson wrote to his father, a Confederate soldier named Andrew DeVilbiss sent the following to his wife, offering his impressions of the battle's aftermath. (DeVilbiss self-censored the epithet concerning Northern soldiers. Both this letter and the one by Stevenson, above, were published for the first time and in their entirety in BEHIND THE LINES.)

Corinth, Miss.

Dear Mary:     

I hurriedly write you a few lines to let you know that I am well…. I am anxious you should hear from me. It is given up to be the hardest fought battle on the American Continent.     

The Yankee camps, that we took were beautifully located with fine springs running down in branches, but on Monday morning I saw those branches having their waters all colored with blood. O Mary you could never form an idea of the horrors of actual war unless you saw the battlefields while the conflict is progressing. Death in every awful form, if it really be death, is a pleasant sight in comparison to the fearfully and mortally wounded. Some crying oh, my wife, my children, others my Mother, my sister, my brother etc. any and all of these terms you will hear while some pray to God to have mercy and the others die cursing the “Yankee sons of b_____s.”     

It is a grand and awful sight to and one that can never be forgotten.

My leg is yet a little black from the spent minnie ball that struck me, as I told you in my letter before. I am thankful to God for bringing me safely through. Go to the Church and thank him also, and pray for my preservation, and tell my boys to do the same. The man waits. Good bye. God bless you.

Andrew

P.S. Write to me by mail. I may have better luck here, and send otherwise, when you can. Your affectionate husband

Both Stevenson and DeVilbiss would later be killed in the war.

NEXT WEEK: An extraordinary letter from Pearl Harbor by a young sailor trapped inside the U.S.S. New Orleans .

Sound Off...What do you think? Join the discussion.

Copyright 2008 Lines of Fire. All opinions expressed in this article are the author's and do not necessarily reflect those of Military.com.

 
About Lines of Fire

Military.com is proud to announce LINES OF FIRE, a collaboration with the Legacy Project to feature a war letter (or e-mail) on this site each week for the next year. Since 1998, Americans have shared with the Legacy Project an estimated 75,000 letters from every conflict in U.S. history, including e-mails from Operation Enduring Freedom and Operation Iraqi Freedom.

The Legacy Project is a national, all-volunteer effort that works to honor and remember American veterans by preserving their correspondences for posterity. "There are no greater experts on the subject of warfare than the men and women who have experienced it firsthand," says Legacy Project founder Andrew Carroll. He adds: "Our mission is to encourage veterans, active duty troops, and their families to save these irreplaceable letters and e-mails so that we can better understand the sacrifices they have made -- and continue to make -- for every one of us."

Andrew Carroll will personally select the letters for this special LINES OF FIRE series, some of which have been published in his national bestseller WAR LETTERS: Extraordinary Correspondence from American Wars or the recently-published BEHIND THE LINES: Powerful and Revealing American and Foreign War Letters -- And One Man's Search to Find Them. But Carroll will also provide letters and e-mails exclusively to Military.com that have never been published, and he will add "behind the scenes" commentary relating to each selection.

For more information about the Legacy Project's mission, please visit their website: www.warletters.com